Why I don't believe this Magnum PI clip

Look, I loved Magnum PI like everyone else did. And I LOVE 1980s baseball... so you would think this clip of Magnum at a bar with Tigers greats Alan Trammell and Lou Whitaker would be goosebump worthy for me.But there's something about it that doesn't ring true for me. Watch the clip and we'll discuss it.Magnum is such a huge Tigers fan and yet he doesn't recognize the greatest double play combo